I of course do not have a ballot but here are my selections of candidates worthy of enshrinement. The ballot is overcrowded (of course) due to circumstances we are all well aware of and I will touch on later.
Some explanation is in order to explain the slash lines that follow the player’s name. For example here is one of my favorite players on the ballot:
Don Mattingly 23/111/134/34/263
The first number 23, which was ironically enough also Mattingly’s uniform number is actually his career BLACK INK NUMBER. This is in reference to the old Baseball Encyclopedia. If a player led his league in any offensive, defensive, or pitching category during his career it was listed in bolded black ink. An average HOF (Hall of Famer) scores 27 for a batter and 40 for a pitcher by this method.
Gray ink again refers to the Encyclopedia. If a player was amongst the top 10 leaders in his league the stat would be listed in grey italics. A point system was created which you can see in more detail here: http://www.baseball-reference.com/about/leader_glossary.shtml#gray_ink. They also have more details about most of the other systems I am using to evaluate players. Mattingly’s Gray Ink number is 111. An average HOF played scores 144 for a batter or 185 for a pitcher by this method.
Hall of Fame Monitor is a scoring system created by baseball writer and Boston Red Sox consultant Bill James. Details on how this works can be found here: http://www.baseball-reference.com/about/leader_glossary.shtml#hof_monitor. A score of 100 or better is a likely HOF player no matter the position by this method. Mattingly scores a 134 by this method.
Hall of Fame Standards is a measurement of key numbers that get a player into the Hall. I believe this was also a Bill James Construct. Details on how it is calculated can be found here: http://www.baseball-reference.com/about/leader_glossary.shtml#hof_standard. Scores of 50 or higher are likely Hall candidates with this number. Mattingly scores a 34.
“Win Shares” is another Bill James invention. A highly complex formula whose details can be summed up here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Win_shares. 300 or better is a likely candidate. Mattingly scores a 263 by this method.
Enough with the explanation, now we move onto the actual ballot. Looking at first ballot players, we start with the Atlanta Braves dynamic pitching duo of:
Greg Maddux 87/336/254/70/398
Tom Glavine 29/202/176/52/314
If we waited another year it would be a trio as John Smoltz is not eligible to until next year. Together this duo has 6 Cy Young awards amongst them (4 for Maddux and two for Glavine). They combined for a total of 660 wins (355 for Maddux and 305 for Glavine) and 5978 strikeouts (3371 for Maddux 2607 for Glavine).
Maddux was the uber nerd, relying on his intellect and knowledge of batters’ tendencies. Probably the first true saber metric orientated athlete to make extensive use of his laptop computer. On the list of top ten players most similar to Maddux, only one, Roger Clemens is not yet in the Hall of Fame.
Glavine was a 5 time 20 game winner. He was a great left handed compliment to Maddux and together they were a volatile one, two punch in Atlanta for 10 years. On Glavine’s list of similar players, 4 are already in the Hall of Fame, Randy Johnson is not yet eligible and Tommy John and Jim Kaat are borderline candidates.
Frank Thomas 21/200/194/60/405
Jeff Kent 0/71/122/51/339
Frank Thomas was the “Big Hurt” in Chicago for 16 years. One of the most feared hitters throughout his career; sadly he missed the World Series in 2005 due to injury. Thomas managed to smash 521 Homers without the taint of steroids. The ball coming off his bat often sounded like a shotgun blast.
Jeff Kent is an unusual Hall of famer as he didn’t seem to hit his stride until he was 30. By that point he was already with his 4th organization having been traded by the Blue Jays, Mets and Indians before finding his home in San Francisco. He would spend 6 years in San Francisco before moving on to Houston and then Los Angeles with the Dodgers. He is the career leader in home runs for a second baseman with 377.
Barry Bonds 69/289/340/76/661
Roger Clemens 100/320/332/73/421
Both Bonds and Clemens should not even be on this crowded ballot as they should have been elected the previous year.
Bond’s holds the season record for homeruns with 73 in 2001 and career record with 762. He was so feared as a hitter that he was walked 232 times in 2004. He was the ultimate combination of power and speed and he was an excellent defender in his earlier years.
The Clemens trial was one of the biggest jokes and waste of taxpayers’ money in history. A needle in a beer can and a un-witnessed conversation between him and Andy Petitte. Jose Canseco even said Clemens was not a juicer. Either way 354 wins, 4672 strikeouts and 7 Cy Young Awards later, Clemens is Hall of Famer in my book.
Craig Biggio 17/104/469/57/411
Another second baseman goes to the “Hall”. An incredibly versatile ball player, Biggio came us a Catcher, moved to CF to save his knees and then to 2B. He moved back to CF when the Astros had a need and then back to 2B again. While doing this he accumulated 3060 hits, 668 doubles, 291 homers and a slash line of .281/.363/.433. One reporter refuses to vote for him because he was once a teammate of confessed steroid user Ken Caminitti -disgraceful.
Mike Piazza 0/138/202/52/321
Famously picked in the 62nd round of the 1988 amateur draft as a favor to his godfather Tommy Lasorda I have to admit it makes a good candidate for a Faustian bargain. I imagine many in the organization would have considered the pick as a joke and the temptation to use PEDs could have reared its ugly head. That being said, there is no credible evidence that he heard that temptations call let alone gave into its whims. The best hitting catcher of all time deserves a place in the “Hall”, no matter had bad his defense was.
Tim Raines 20/114/90/47/390
I have a feeling the only reason Tim is not in is to spite me. In 1998 announcers would go on and on about how the Yankees had no clear cut Hall of Fame Players. Jeter was only 3 years into his career. What about Tim Raines? He was a role player on that team. Over shadowed somewhat by the greatest leadoff hitter of all time, Rickey Henderson, Raines was no slouch out of the leadoff spot or batting 3rd which he often did with the Expos. Raines didn’t have Henderson’s power but he was just as good with his bat control and speed. Raines managed to post a career slash line of .294/.385/.425 and swiped 808 bases. He did have a cocaine problem which he dealt with on his own.
Alan Trammell 0/48/118/40/318
He should have won the MVP in 1987 and would have a better candidate than his teammate Willie Hernandez in 1984. Trammel was an elite shortstop and along with Lou Whitaker (another viable HOF candidate, who is not on the ballot anymore) formed a dynamic keystone combination. This is Trammell’s 13th year on the ballot. He is over-shadowed by contemporaries Cal Ripken and Barry Larkin and has largely been forgotten since the holy trinity of Jeter/ARod/Garciaparra has appeared. He was more than their equal and deserves a plaque.
These are my ten slots. I am planning follow-up article to discuss those who came close but did not make the cut.
Sunday, January 5, 2014
"If I Had A Vote."
Posted by Tony at 7:26 PM
Labels: "If I Had A Vote."
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment